Podcast Episode 316: Mark Roderick, Flaster Greenberg
The Lawyer's View of Real Estate Crowdfunding
WHITE BOARD WORKSHOP
The Investor Acquisition System
Mark is the foremost attorney specializing in real estate crowdfunding in America.
He was among the pioneers who saw the connection between the JOBS Act of 2012, intended as it was for small businesses, and real estate.
Understanding that the ability for real estate sponsors to advertise their projects online in order to raise capital, Mark saw a new industry was about to emerge, bringing together digital marketing and real estate capital formation..
See below for more links to Mark's online profiles.
What You're Going to Learn
* That you CAN syndicate real estate online - and why
* How to raise money from anyone, anywhere, anytime
* Real estate is crowdfunding's success story
* How to raise $14 million online
* How to build trust through authenticity
* The future of real estate crowdfunding
* The risks and opportunities to watch for
And much, much more.
Listen To or Watch the Full Podcast Here
How to Use the Internet to Legally Raise Money for Real Estate
Adam: Tell me a little bit about the story of how you came to this and how it occurred to you that this was a marketing opportunity.
Mark: I have been practicing law since roughly 1840, as I always say, and in the course of practicing law, what I have always done is represented entrepreneurs in everything they do. One thing entrepreneurs spend a lot of time doing is trying to raise capital, because every entrepreneur needs capital. That's why they call it capitalism, because capital is what runs the machine.
I have been involved in helping entrepreneurs raise capital since forever, and when I saw the JOBS Act on the horizon, I said to myself, "Wow. We will be able to advertise." What that means is that the internet is coming to the capital-formation industry. That was the observation. I don't even want to call it insight.
By that time, the internet had already come to a number of industries; retail, as an example; the travel industry; the book-selling industry; all these industries. When the internet comes to an industry, it always does the same thing in an industry-specific context. It always directly connects buyers and sellers, over the head, and displacing all the middlemen.
If you think about what you and I both know about what the capital-formation industry used to be - that series of disconnected networks - those are all middlemen. I say that in Manhattan, from the East River to the Hudson, that's just middlemen; all those people are just middlemen.
Knowing what the internet has done to all these other industries, I said to myself, "Wow, that ... I mean, books? Yeah, that's a big industry, but capital formation, that is a multi-trillion-dollar-a-year industry. When the internet hits that industry, you are going to see some real disruption." That's when I decided that I'd really like to get into this business. Then it immediately became apparent that there's a billion websites out there, probably more. I don't know, there's probably 100,000 more every day.
A lot of them have really cool stuff on them; really interesting stuff. I said a few seconds ago, you could put up a website today to raise money for a business, but man, you are competing with a billion websites. A lot of those websites, I'm sorry, but they have photos of really attractive people [cross talk] ... You've got to compete with that.
That's when I realized, now, we've gone from a world of only being able to talk to six people to raise money ... Now, we're going to be able to talk to a world of 6 billion people. How is my voice going to be heard in all that commotion? That's when I started to say and must have said thousands of times since - crowdfunding is a marketing business.
Real Estate is Crowdfunding's Success Story
Adam: You represent real-estate sponsors, real-estate developers in their securities laws, or security-laws aspects of their fundraising, their capital-raising. What have you seen, in terms of the way that they have begun to adapt to this new environment, to this new opportunity to raise capital online, because it's a fundamental shift, isn't it, Mark?
Mark: It absolutely is. Just a couple of thoughts there. One, as you know, when crowdfunding began, no one was thinking about real estate. Nobody was thinking about real estate. Because this was a new internet phenomenon, people thought, "Oh, this is Silicon Valley. Now we're going to put the next Facebook, or the next Instagram on ..." You could be able to invest in it. Nobody thought about real estate.
I wrote a blog post soon thereafter, thinking, hmm ... Saying maybe real estate would [cross talk] pretty good thing, and not because of my blog post, but just because of the inherent nature of the animal, suddenly real estate became and continues to be the, by far, huge success story.
Of course, we think - no one knows for sure - why has real estate been so successful? Nothing else has really been successful. We think it's because when people are investing online, they see an apartment building - that apartment building in Austin. They know what apartment buildings are. Everyone's been a tenant at some time. They know about rent, so they think they understand it. Whether they do or not is different question, but they think they do, so they're willing to invest.
But I have another idea. I think that's absolutely true. What we have seen ... Crowdfunding is a new thing. To go from doing things the way you've always done them to doing something completely new requires a certain kind of person. Lots of them live in California; lots live in New York. None live in Philadelphia, just about, which is where I am ...
If you think about, in the business world, who is really, really entrepreneurial, the answer is real estate. Real-estate folks are cowboys; real-estate folks are risk-takers, as a general proposition. It may be that that's another reason why real estate has migrated so successfully from offline to online. They were just willing to do it, and the results have been amazing. In the beginning, people were doing a little single-family fix-and-flip and raising $120,000. Couple months ago, one of my clients raised $14 million dollars for a single real-estate project.
Adam: Isn't it incredible-
Mark: It's incredible.
Adam: Did you see one of the websites raised- one of the marketplaces raised $5 million in three minutes, last week, they announced.
Mark: There you go.
Adam: It was extraordinary.
Mark: Of course, success begets success, because when real-estate developers out there start hearing stories like the one you just told, their ears perk up. "What?! What?! $5 million dollars? Three minutes? What?!" [cross talk] It's a success that feeds on itself.
How to Raise $14 Million Online
Adam: Although it has outstripped other industries, it still has an enormous way to go. One of the things that you mentioned was that is that taking marketing online is something very, very different. My question to you is: is it really? Is it actually something really very different?
Mark: You know what? That is a question that I would turn around and ask you, because ... I'm serious, because as I always tell people, I am just a boring corporate-securities lawyer. The value lies in the marketing. I will ask you - is marketing a real-estate apartment building in Austin online, is that different than marketing soap? How is it different?
Adam: Well, it's not ... In terms of marketing soap, it's ... What I meant was it's actually the exact same as marketing the old way, only it's done online. The same process has to be engaged.
If I'm meeting you for the first time, and I've got a deal at Walk and Crosswalk, the first thing we're going to talk about is who am I, who are you? We'll get to know each other. We might have lunch together - the old way. Over time, you'll get to know me, and you'll come to like me and eventually trust me enough to send me a check for the deal, if the numbers make sense.
Online, it's the exact same thing. You still have to establish a relationship with a prospect. You just do it's in a different way - online. That's really the fundamental difference.
What I was interested to know is what have you seen, in terms of your clients who have adopted this? For example, your client that raised $14 million, I'm assuming that they used digital marketing in some way. They went online and they did it.
What was it for them, in your experience, or for other clients that you have that has enabled that mindset to go from the old way, the traditional way, to adopting that you use your phone, basically, now to communicate. What makes [cross talk]
Mark: This client, and this kind of right fits in with what you said ... One, they raised the money through one of the marketplaces, CrowdStreet. CrowdStreet, as you know, has a large pool of online investors, but this $14 million raise was their third offering on CrowdStreet.
Maybe what's happening there ... You talked about you and I meeting, going out to lunch. Maybe what has happened is that sponsor has formed a relationship, essentially, with these investors. Things went well in the first deal. Things went well in the second deal. By the time he got to the third deal, investors were just saying, "Where do I sign."
Then, of course, there's this weird herd mentality that I think has always been there in the investment community; everyone wants to jump on something that they see other people jumping on. I think you're seeing some of that now in the online-investing platform.
For example, the situation you just said- you said they raised either $3 million in 5 minutes, or $5 million in three minutes [cross talk] In either case, those investors were not, during those precious few minutes, carefully analyzing the deal, and looking at the pro forma, and just speed-reading ... They were engaged in some other kind of psychological behavior. I guess when you're marketing these deals, that's the behavior that you're trying to stimulate.
How to Build Trust Through Authenticity
Adam: How did you get your name and your story out there, when you first discovered the opportunity of crowdfunding?
Mark: Well, I've been accused of being incredibly good-looking and athletic. I can understand all those things, but I've never been accused of being a great marketer, and I'm really not, in any intentional way. This is what happened for me. I saw this ...
Interestingly, I think this is important to note, I didn't see crowdfunding as a business opportunity. I saw crowdfunding as something that was incredibly exciting and also something that was an incredible social good, having to do with the democratization of capital and letting entrepreneurs have access to capital, no matter where they lived and where their father was, or whether he was in their lives, or where all these other things; giving ordinary Americans access to great deals.
So, I saw it as an exciting project and one where there would be enormous social benefits. I therefore became sort of - and still am - evangelical about it. I started to write this blog, which may well be where you ... It turned out that I had a skill at a blog writing. I'd never done it before, but ...
My point is I think that my personal enthusiasm comes out in the blog and when I do public speaking, which I do a fair amount. It is actually that completely sincere personal enthusiasm, rather than any particular marketing message that would be crafted through focus groups and so forth.
I think that has been my claim to fame in the crowdfunding space, and that, too, is a virtuous cycle, because the more people I speak to - you -the more I learn, and more I learn, the more I have to offer. It's been a real eye-opening lesson for me that, when you really believe in something and are enjoying what you do, it seems to rub off it. It seems to affect people.
The Future of Real Estate Crowdfunding
Adam: Where do you think this is headed? In 10 years' time or ultimately, what do you think this industry is going to look like?
Mark: Well, I analogize it to all these other industries that the internet has penetrated and disrupted. It will continue to expand, as more and more investors become aware of it; as more and more sponsors become aware of it. In my $14 million deal, there were something like 280 investors, which is great. I believe that the sites, like CrowdStreet, RealCrowd - the big successful sites - I think they might have a couple hundred thousand accredited investors signed up. There's like 8 million accredited investors-
Adam: Exactly, though, right?
Mark: -in this country. We are talking about they are scratching the surface. As sponsors become aware of raising $14 million, more and more people are going to come into the industry, which will be great. I think, within a short period of time, just as ... When we're going to make a travel plan, now, if I'm going to go out to visit my sister in California, I'm going online. I mean, it doesn't occur twice.
I think, in the real-estate field, particularly, it's not going to be long before a sponsor thinks first about going online to raise capital just as a natural move. I'm hopeful that it moves from the accredited-investor-only world into the Reg-A non-accredited-investor world.
As you've noted, the Reg-A world, so far, has been much less successful than I think many of us thought that it would. The Reg-D world, accredited investors only, is so much more successful, so, I think that's going to happen.
Now, with that said, what the internet does is drives out inefficiencies in markets. I said that it displaces middlemen. That's a different way of saying the same thing. It drives out inefficiencies. At some deal size - I don't know what it is; exactly what it is ... The world of $100,000 deals is extremely inefficient. The world of $14 million deals is still inefficient. Crowdfunding can grow beyond there.
The world of, let's say, a billion-dollar real-estate deal, that is an efficient world. It's already efficient. Everyone knows who all the players are. Everyone has access to information. There are experts out there. That's an efficient market already.
Crowdfunding, I think, doesn't have a role to play in that market. I don't know where the line is. We haven't reached it yet, and given that we've only penetrated less than 10 percent, even of the accredited-investor market, we have a long way to go. There does become some point where crowdfunding is not adding any efficiencies to the markets, which is fine. All all of us want is efficient markets. If it's crowdfunding, great; and if it's not, great.
Adam: It'll reach its maximum potential, basically.
Mark: It will, yeah.
Watch for These Risks and Opportunities
Mark: It has a long way to go. As I'm in the industry, it looks great to me. I always- when I speak at conferences, I'll say, "From our end of the telescope - the industry end - things look great." If you get on the other side of the telescope, from the investor side, it doesn't look that great, still.
The websites aren't great. The process isn't great. There's no standardization. No one is really reading the legal documents. What's the point of all this legal disclosure, if no one's looking at it? If you look at it through that end, there's a long ... We're still, I think, in Version 1.0. We have lots of versions yet to develop.
Adam: To go through, yeah, including the one that will be forged during the next downturn.
Mark: Whoo! Are there such things as real-estate downturns?
Adam: Ah! Keeps on going up, Mark. You know that.
Mark: I will tell you, Adam, it's really ... On the marketing side, that is going to drive what the future of crowdfunding is. You're going to drive it a lot more than ... I mean, I may prepare standardized legal documents and all that stuff, but you marketing folks are really going to drive what crowdfunding becomes, and that can be for good or bad.
REITs have been around forever. REITS kind of were supposed to be crowdfunding a long time ago, and they took a wrong turn. Private REITs became just not-good investments; high commissions. I've always been concerned that crowdfunding could take that same kind of turn.
I speak with lots of people, and I've spoken with some bad people, who have been trying to kind of turn Regulation A into a boiler room. They're telling me, "Well, we don't care what the deal is. We can sell anything." Well, that's not what I want crowdfunding to become.
Adam: Right. There's a lot of responsibility in [cross talk] real estate; especially when you know, or you've got as long a history in real-estate developments, and finance, as both of we have.
Adam: These are very complicated deals that have good upside, but definitely downside possibilities.
Adam: I feel a deep sense of responsibility to the people that I market to, on behalf of clients, and only work with clients, like you do, that I feel have high integrity and are really doing the very best that they possibly can to be successful; like you say, not just running boiler rooms.
You Can Syndicate Real Estate Online. Here's Why.
Adam: Mark, you really inspired me. We spoke at least a couple of years ago, and you shared with me an incredible insight that the changes in regulations allowing real-estate sponsors to raise money online was a marketing opportunity. I really want to talk to you about that. That's what I'm doing now. I provide ... You asked me, I provide marketing, digital marketing, and social-media services to sponsors to raise capital.
Before we get into that, let me ask you one question, and let's address our conversation to those in our audience who still don't know you can do it. Is it legal, first of all, to raise capital online, and if so, tell me the story of how that came to be?
Mark: No, it's not legal at all. What's your next question?
Adam: What are you doing for lunch? That's all right. We'll cancel now.
Mark: Okay. My answer is going to go back many years into American history, but then it's going to really quickly come back up to date, so don't think I'm going to go month to month. We had a Great (world) Depression, back in the 1920s, as everyone knows, I believe ... Actually, you know, I don't know whether people younger than me do know-
Adam: You were there, of course, right?
Mark: My grandparents lived through it, so I am maybe the last generation that actually remembers we had a Great Depression; not just in this country but all over the world. It led to the rise of Nazi Germany and all kinds of bad things.
One of the causes of the Great Depression in this country was that American capital markets had become basically a swamp filled with investor fraud, and stock-market manipulation, and so on, and so forth. When you live in a capitalist country, as we do, and your capital markets collapse, you have a depression.
As I'm sure all your listeners know, Franklin Roosevelt was elected president for the first time in 1932. One of the very first things he did teaming up with a Texas Democrat named Sam Rayburn, who went on to an extremely illustrious career ... They teamed up and wrote the US securities laws, as we now know them.
It's not a coincidence that all of the securities laws that you read about today, you read on the internet. Well, what laws you know affect cryptocurrencies, these brand-new digital assets? People are always talking about the Securities Act of 1933, the Exchange Act of 1934, the Investment Company Act of 1940. It's not a coincidence that those laws were written at that time, because they were written in direct response to the collapse of our capital markets in the late 1920s.
The result is, in this country, we got the most stringent, transparent securities laws in the world. A result of that has been we- not coincidentally, we have the most efficient, most trusted, and most valuable capital markets in the world.
I go back into that history, to give your listeners - that person that you referred to who's not sure whether we can do all this - some sense of the history behind the rules. Ever since the 1930s, since the 1933 act, there have been a few fundamental rules about American securities laws. One of the most fundamental rules that every young securities lawyer learns at his mother's knee is that there is a difference between public offerings of securities and private offerings of securities.
The difference is, in a public offering, you can advertise a ... Oh, let's take an old-school company, General Motors, or a new-school company, Uber. Those companies can advertise their securities publicly. "Here, come buy our securities," they can say in The Wall Street Journal.
Conversely, a private company, a real-estate developer buying an apartment building in Austin, for example, could not advertise, and everyone knows that. Instead of advertising, that developer has to know people, or know people who know people, or know people who know people who know people. Very inefficient series of barely connected private networks, basically.
Now, I'm finally going to answer your question. It is that longstanding rule that was changed in 2012, when then President Barack Obama signed into law the JOBS Act of 2012 on, I believe, May 5th, 2012. Although there's lots of complicated rules included in that law, the single thing that transformed the capital-formation industry is a reversal of that 85-year-old rule.
Whereas you could not advertise before the JOBS Act, after the JOBS Act, you can advertise virtually any way you want. In fact, when I'm ... I do a lot of public speaking, and I'll be moderating a panel of lawyers, and I will say, "What kind of advertising can you not do under Rule 506(c)?" People get a little bit of a worried expression on their face, like, "Don't ask me ..." It's a trick question, because there is no advertising that you cannot do under rule 506(c).
I've probably been talking long enough, but you said, "How do you go about doing it?" As you know, there are three kinds of crowdfunding, and we can talk about those if you want to, but they all have in common the reversal of this longstanding rule. You can now advertise your private deal publicly.
You Really Can Raise Money From Anyone, Anywhere, Anytime
Mark: Crowdfunding is just a minor, in technical detail - though major in impact - change to the 1933 Securities Laws.
Adam: Right. Let's just drill down on it, to be really, really clear. Some of the clauses, for example, that a lot of sponsors may still have in their contracts are no longer relevant. For example, you don't have to ... What's the word? You don't have to warrant, or represents that a sponsor has a pre-existing relationship with an investor, right?
Mark: That's correct. That's-
Adam: An investor doesn't- go ahead.
Mark: Well, yes. It used to be, these private networks, you could only raise money from someone you knew, or someone they knew, or someone they knew. The technical word ... You've become a lawyer now, I can tell. You're not just doing marketing.
Adam: Well, I've just been listening to all your podcasts [cross talk] internalized them all.
Mark: Yeah, now you're using this technical term 'pre-existing relationship.' That's what you used to have to have, but no longer. In the post-JOBS Act world, you can you know bring in any investor from anywhere. I always get a chill when I say this, even though I say it all the time, is that back in the pre-2012 world, all the clients I used to represent, they had to go looking for money - make phone calls, and go to meetings, and go to meetings after meetings, and on, and on.
Today, I always say - now, I'm going to get a chill - but, as you know, if you want to raise money for real estate ... Adam, you say, "God, I just had a great idea for a business!" As soon as we get off this podcast, you can put up a website, and you can theoretically reach every investor in the world. I got that chill, but that's what it's all about. Far from having to have a pre-existing relationship, you can get money from anyone anywhere.
WHITE BOARD WORKSHOP
The Investor Acquisition System
Website Disclaimer: All Content contained on this website is intended for informational purposes only and does not purport to be complete or accurate. No recommendations are made or intended to be made regarding investment in real estate of any kind. For further information on any investment opportunity contained in any content of this website, you should visit the respective crowdfunding portal or site where such investment opportunity is published. None of the content presented on this website has been prepared with any reference to any particular user’s investment requirements or financial situation, and you are encouraged to consult with professional tax, legal and financial advisors before making any investment decisions or including the decision to invest at all. GowerCrowd makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy of any information and accepts no liability or fiduciary responsibility whatsoever. Offers to sell, or the solicitations of offers to buy, any security can only be made through official offering documents through registered portals outside of this website. Investors should conduct their own due diligence, not rely on the financial assumptions or estimates displayed on this website, and are encouraged to consult with a financial advisor, attorney, accountant, and any other professional that can help you to understand and assess the risks associated with any investment opportunity. Neither Adam Gower nor GowerCrowd or any related entities are a registered broker-dealer, funding portal, or investment advisor and does not conduct any activity that would require any registration as such.