A Starter Guide on Preferred Equity
By Adam Gower Ph.D.
Preferred equity is one of those financial concepts that a lot of investors believe they understand, and yet each may have a different concept in mind which can lead to confusion and misunderstanding.
This article provides guidance on the definition of preferred equity, and how you can tell the difference between the different types.
Simply stated, there are two types of capital that are used in any real estate transaction; debt and equity.
The main difference between these two types of capital is that debt will only be repaid with interest, whereas equity is commonly paid a type of interest (usually called a ‘preferred return’), plus, importantly, a share of the profits.
Each of these categories of finance can be broken down into different subcategories.
For example, there are different kinds of debt; senior debt, most often provided by banks, second-position debt which is subordinate to senior debt, and even third and fourth position debt, and so on, each subordinate to each other sequentially.
All types of debt are considered loans to the property and are typically secured by recorded liens on the property.
Liens against the underlying real property are put in place so that should the borrower stop paying as agreed to any lender there is a formal record of the obligation.
Using the foreclosure process, lenders can institute recovery efforts potentially culminating in their taking possession of a property away from a borrower.
Mezzanine debt financing comes last after other types of debt, is always subordinate to any other recorded debt, but is ahead of all equity.
However, mezzanine debt does not record a lien against the property itself as collateral.
Instead mezzanine debt secures its position with a claim against the equity in the deal via a UCC financing statement filed against the partnership interest.
Despite not securing its position against an interest in the underlying real property, mezzanine financing is considered a loan to the project and mezzanine holders are considered to be lenders which affords them different recovery rights than equity holders.
The Capital Stack
At the bottom of the stack (see illustration above) the most stable of all the capital; the foundational capital upon which all other funding is placed, is the bank debt, with a 1st position mortgage, also known as senior debt.
On top of that might by another layer of debt, the second position debt.
Then follows the mezzanine debt, then the equity which might be split between preferred and common equity.
Generally, second position debt will earn an interest rate higher than that in first position because it bears higher risk.
Mezzanine debt is so called because it sits in between two different types of capital and is the last layer of financing before the equity layer in the capital stack.
During the financial crisis of 2008-2009 banks discovered challenges foreclosing on properties that had a layer of mezzanine debt on them.
Mezzanine holders acting in their capacity as lenders to projects, were able to exercise outsized influence on the control of the real property and therefore banks now include in their loan documents prohibitions against adding extra layers of debt, including mezzanine debt, on top of the senior position.
To fill the gap that the absence of mezzanine debt left, preferred equity is increasingly used in its place.
Like mezzanine debt, preferred equity is subordinate to all debt, and superior to common equity.
Preferred equity does not receive a share of the profits of the transaction and yet, as its name suggests, preferred equity is not debt and investors in preferred equity are not treated like lenders.
But if preferred equity investors are not considered lenders to the project – a key contrast to mezzanine debt - and yet don't share in the profits, as typical equity investors might expect, what are they?
FREE Real estate syndication education and insight newsletter. Subscribe now.
The mechanism by which investors can secure their interests that differentiates preferred equity from mezzanine debt is as follows:
Preferred equity holders, as members of the LLC controlling the real estate, can in the event of default take over control of the LLC.
In the case of preferred equity, recourse is strictly a function of the structure of the operating entity and the relationship between the various parties.
And because preferred equity holders are simply a different class of shareholder in the company that is operating the real estate project, they do not represent another layer of secured debt and consequently pose reduced compliance issues with lenders.
Mezzanine debt holders are not members of the LLC, but their recourse is to take possession of the LLC in its entirety in the event of default, through a UCC foreclosure.
This contrasts with a debt lender with a lien against the property who would take over ownership of the real property itself - preferred equity and mezzanine debt investors take over ownership of the partnership that owns the property.
While the intent of preferred equity is to fill whatever the gap was left by mezzanine debt, there is a broad array of different rights and remedies that can be built into an operating agreement.
Consequently, sophisticated investors should take into consideration what these rights and remedies are when comparing different preferred equity investments – no two ‘preferred equity’ structures are the same and, in fact, can be very different.
Soft v. Hard Pay
One way in which preferred equity positions can be very different from each other is the manner in which they are paid; soft or hard.
Hard pay functions more like a debt-instrument where if there's a non-payment there are some punitive remedies.
The operating agreement will say that the operating entity has to make a certain payment on the first of every month, and pay off the entire loan within a certain period of time, let’s say 3 years.
If the entity, controlled by the sponsor, doesn’t make any of those payments, pure ‘hard pay’ remedies that could be enforced could include wiping out all the subordinate equity, and taking over control of the partnership interest.
In this sense it is pretty much identical to mezzanine debt.
And it is precisely for this reason that banks don’t like hard pay preferred equity positions.
The bank is lending to the sponsor and does not like subordinate positions to have the right to take over the operating entity they are lending to.
Soft pay terms, more acceptable to lenders, just require the sponsor, or the operating entity, to make payments when there is sufficient cash-flow to be able to make payments and if there is a failure to pay, there may or may not be remedies the preferred equity holders can employ.
Furthermore, while preferred equity is paid before common equity, there may be ‘hard pay’ terms that set aside a preferred interest reserve.
The preferred equity holders will be paid out of this reserve, even though common equity holders may receive first distributions of income from cash flow.
Risks to Unsophisticated Investors
This combination of different interests and options can create additional risks for unsophisticated investors.
If a sponsor puts together a deal that works in their best interests, like a soft-pay preferred equity deal, they may be able to put this in front of a crowd that doesn’t understand whether the deal is good or bad.
In essence, it could allow the sponsor to have a free option with the preferred equity money.
Consequently, there are vast differences between types of preferred equity.
Investors should be keenly aware that their rights can be materially affected in one kind of preferred equity versus another and should be conscious of what their rights are before making an investment.
The Impact of Crowdfunding on Real Estate Waterfall Structures By Adam Gower Ph.D. Waterfall calculations are used by real estate developers to calculate distributions to investors during the life cycle of a project and there have been some notable shifts in how they are structured since the emergence of real estate crowdfunding – with significant…READ MORE >
Real Estate Waterfalls – The Simpler the Better By Adam Gower Ph.D. Real estate syndications use what are called ‘waterfalls’ to structure and compensate principals and investors, and these are seldom altered once a developer creates a structure that works for them. There are, however, a vast array of ways in which waterfalls are designed…READ MORE >
7 Ways You Can Invest in Commercial Real Estate Online By Adam Gower Ph.D. According to the research site, Statista, commercial real estate development in the United States has been steadily growing since 2010. Meanwhile, vacancy rates for these properties have been declining. What that tells us is there is continued demand for commercial property, and…READ MORE >
Copyright 2018 - ADAM GOWER PH.D. - All Rights Reserved
Website Disclaimer: All Content contained on this website is intended for informational purposes only and does not purport to be complete or accurate. No recommendations are made or intended to be made regarding investment in real estate of any kind. For further information on any investment opportunity contained in any content of this website, you should visit the respective crowdfunding portal or site where such investment opportunity is published. None of the content presented on this website has been prepared with any reference to any particular user’s investment requirements or financial situation, and you are encouraged to consult with professional tax, legal and financial advisors before making any investment decisions or including the decision to invest at all. GowerCrowd makes no representations or warranties as to the accuracy of any information and accepts no liability or fiduciary responsibility whatsoever. Offers to sell, or the solicitations of offers to buy, any security can only be made through official offering documents through registered portals outside of this website. Investors should conduct their own due diligence, not rely on the financial assumptions or estimates displayed on this website, and are encouraged to consult with a financial advisor, attorney, accountant, and any other professional that can help you to understand and assess the risks associated with any investment opportunity. Neither Adam Gower nor GowerCrowd or any related entities are a registered broker-dealer, funding portal, or investment advisor and does not conduct any activity that would require any registration as such.